Welcome to the new School of Marketing podcast. I'm Bianca McKenzie, and this is the place where we break down marketing strategies that actually work without the overwhelm.
Before we dive in, I want to acknowledge the traditional owners of the land I live and work on, the Palawa people of Lutarita. I pay my respects to elders past and present and acknowledge the deep connection they have to this land, culture and community.
Now let's dive in and make marketing work for you.
Here's something I want you to think about before we get into today's episode.
The last piece of marketing advice you implemented,
where did it come from?
Who gave it?
What kind of business do they run?
How big is their team?
How long have they been in business?
What's their revenue model?
Where do they live?
Who do they serve?
Because here's what I've been thinking about a lot lately.
The marketing advice industry has a significant problem.
And that problem is that most of the advice being consumed by small business owners is coming from people whose businesses look nothing like theirs.
And when you apply advice that was designed for a completely different context to your specific situation,
it almost never works the way it was supposed to.
And then you blame yourself.
Today we're talking about that,
why the advice gap exists,
what it is costing you,
and how to get much better at filtering what's actually relevant to your business versus what's noise dressed up as wisdom.
Let's start by understanding how marketing advice actually gets created and distributed.
Because I think once you see the mechanics of it,
you'll never consume it quite the same way again.
The people who produce the most marketing advice,
the biggest podcast,
the most followed Instagram accounts,
the highest, you know, profile courses,
they're almost always people who have built large online audiences.
That's how they became prominent enough to be seen as authorities.
Which means the very thing that gave them their platform is the thing they most often teach.
Fair enough, right?
They built an audience through content marketing,
so they teach content marketing.
They grew through online launches, so they teach launches.
They scale through a membership model, so they teach memberships.
They cracked Instagram,
so they teach Instagram.
And the advice they give is genuinely good for someone in their situation.
For someone with their audience size, their revenue base, their team,
their content infrastructure,
their existing credibility.
For someone who is,
in many meaningful ways, already successful and trying to grow further.
But you might not be that person.
You might be a local service business trying to get more inquiries from your community.
You might be a tradie who's never posted on LinkedIn in your life.
You might be a regional retailer whose customers are mostly over 60 and don't use Instagram.
You might be a course creator with 200 email subscribers who's being advised to launch like someone with 20,000.
The advice isn't wrong,
the context is wrong.
And context is everything.
There's a specific version of this I want to name because I think it's particularly pervasive and damaging.
There is a category of marketing educator, and I want to be. I want to be really careful here because not everyone who teaches marketing falls into this,
like, absolutely not.
But there is a category whose primary business is teaching marketing.
Their revenue comes from selling courses, memberships, masterminds, and events about marketing.
They're not primarily running a marketing strategy for a product or service business. They are running a personal brand and an education business.
And those two things require very different marketing approaches.
The person selling a $2,000 marketing course to an audience of 50,000 people,
they can afford to give away a lot of free content because even a tiny conversion rate generates significant revenue.
The person running a service business with the capacity for 10 clients cannot operate the same way.
And I'm not saying there's anything wrong with the first or the second.
I'm highlighting the difference.
The person with a massive online following can afford to experiment with new platforms,
new formats,
new strategies, because their existing audience gives them a safety net.
The person building from scratch cannot do this.
And yes, everybody starts from zero in a way.
It's just they started at a different time.
The person whose entire business model is digital and global can follow advice about building funnels and evergreen courses and passive income.
The person whose business is fundamentally local and relationship based probably shouldn't.
When the marketing guru says this is what works,
what they're really saying is this is what works for my specific type of business,
at my specific scale, with my specific audience.
They're just not always saying that second part out loud.
Let me get specific about the scale problem, because I think it's one of the most common ways this plays out.
A lot of the marketing advice that circulates online is created by people with large audiences,
and the strategies they teach are often optimized for scale. For Reaching thousands of people efficiently.
But most of the business owners I work with don't have thousands of people.
They have hundreds or dozens, or in the early stages, just a handful.
And the strategies that work at scale often work very differently or don't work at all at small audience sizes.
So take launching for example,
the launch model, like, you know, the open cart, closed cart urgency, big email sequence, promotional content blitz, all of that,
that was developed by people with large warm audiences and works because of the law of large numbers.
If you have 10,000 email subscribers and your launch converts at 2%,
that's 200 sales. That is a really,
really successful launch.
If you have 300 email subscribers and you launch with the same model,
converting at 2% gives you six sales,
which is still really good.
But after all that effort, all that content,
all that promotional intensity,
you might feel a bit deflated.
It's not a failed launch because the model doesn't work.
It's a result that reflects the size of the audience, not the quality of the strategy.
But the person with 300 subscribers often doesn't hear that context.
They're hearing, you know, launches work and they run one and they get six sales and they think they've done something wrong.
And the advice wasn't wrong,
the scale wasn't right for it yet.
So the scale problem is one issue,
the business model mismatch is another.
And in some ways it's kind of subtle and more damaging.
Different business models genuinely require different marketing approaches.
And a lot of the advice circulating online assumes one particular business model. You know, the online digital product based or education based content driven model.
And it's like presented as if it's universal, but it's not.
A local cafe doesn't need a content funnel. It needs foot traffic. Go Google reviews and a community presence.
A professional services firm doesn't primarily grow through Instagram.
It's going to grow through referrals, through reputation, through relationships.
A trades business doesn't need a lead magnet and an email welcome sequence.
It needs to show up in search.
When people are looking for what they offer and they need to have enough reviews to be trusted.
When a local business owner follows advice designed for an online course creator, because, you know, that's the advice that is the loudest and the most visible.
They end up doing things that feel wrong and they get poor results and then they just think that they're bad at marketing and they're not bad at marketing. They're just using the wrong map for their territory.
Here's one that's particularly close to my heart, living and working in northwest Tasmania,
a lot of marketing advice is created in and for large urban centers and areas like cities would like. Big populations,
lots of foot traffic,
large local markets, a strong digital infrastructure, and communities that are basically used to engaging with businesses online.
Regional and rural businesses operate in a completely different context.
The population is smaller,
the community dynamics are very different, like everyone knows everyone, which kind of cuts both ways.
The relationship between a business and its community is closer, it's more personal, and in some ways it's more accountable.
What works in Sydney doesn't automatically work in Smithton.
What's expected from a business on Instagram in Melbourne might feel completely out of character for the same business in a regional Tasmanian town.
And yet the advice being consumed by regional business owners is mostly the same advice that is being consumed by the urban business owner,
because that's what's most accessible online.
I've mentored enough local businesses to know that the most effective marketing for many of them looks nothing like what the major marketing educators teach.
It's more local, more relationship focused, more embedded in the community.
It's, you know, sponsoring the footy club,
being at the show,
knowing your customers by name.
It's having a Google business profile that's properly maintained and a Facebook page that the community actually follows because it feels like them.
It's word of mouth that's been intentionally cultivated through giving absolutely amazing service.
None of that is glamorous enough to make someone a marketing guru, but it works for that business in that context, and that's what matters.
There's one more dimension to this that I want to name,
and it's a little bit uncomfortable, but it needs to be said.
Some marketing advice comes from people who haven't been in business long enough to know whether their strategies actually hold up over time.
Someone who built a successful business in the last two or three years, you know,
during a particular economic climate, on a particular platform, with a particular kind of offer,
may have genuinely excellent insights about that specific moment.
But they haven't yet seen how their approach performs through a difficult economic period,
through platform changes, through shifts in consumer behavior. They haven't had time to see what compounds and what fades.
And yet the speed of the online world rewards new voices.
Someone who had a successful launch last year becomes an authority on launching.
Someone who grew their Instagram quickly becomes an authority on Instagram growth.
The credential is recent success. It's not sustained wisdom.
I'm not saying new voices don't have value. They absolutely do, especially for insight into what's working right now on specific platforms,
but sustained, tested, proven wisdom about what actually builds a business over time.
That requires time.
And some of the loudest marketing voices haven't had enough of it yet.
So what are you actually going to do with all of this? You know, how do you get better at filtering the advice that you consume so that you're taking what's actually genuinely relevant and letting the rest go?
So here are some questions that I would encourage you to ask before you implement any marketing advice.
Firstly, what kind of business does this person actually run?
Not their bio, their actual business. You know, how do they make money? What's their revenue model? How big is their team?
Who are their customers, and how do they reach them? How long have they been doing it?
The more you can understand about their actual business,
the better you can assess how applicable their advice is to yours.
Secondly, what was the context when this worked for them?
Results in marketing are always contextual.
What worked for someone in 2021 may not work the same way now.
What works with an audience of 50,000 may not work with an audience of 500.
What worked in a particular niche might not translate to yours.
So ask when did this work and under what conditions before you actually assume that it will work for you in your conditions.
Also, does this advice assume resources that I don't have?
You know, some advice just it assumes that you have a budget, that you have a team, that you have a time allocation or an existing audience that you might not have.
So before you follow the advice,
check what it actually requires. You know, an advice giver who tells you, you know, just hire a videographer for your content.
They're giving advice that assumes that you have a budget and a lot of small business owners just don't have that kind of budget.
Also ask is this advice for my stage of business?
Marketing strategy should look different at different stages. The advice for someone building from zero is different from the advice for someone scaling something that already works.
The advice for someone with a validated offer is different from someone who is still figuring out what their offer actually is.
If the advice assumes a stage of business that you haven't reached yet,
it's probably going to be a little bit premature for you to try that.
Also ask does this feel right for my specific community and context?
Your instincts about what will work in your market, they are worth something.
If a strategy feels completely wrong for your community, your customers, your local context,
pay attention to that feeling because you know your people and the marketing educator giving you advice doesn't.
I do have to say, sometimes you have to step out of your comfort zone a little bit.
But if you're getting massive red flags and go, no, I know this is not going to work, listen to that feeling.
Well,
I don't want to leave you feeling like all marketing advice is, you know, suspicious and that you shouldn't trust anyone. That's not my message.
This message is about being more discerning about whose advice you listen to and actually take action on.
Seek out people who've built businesses that look like the business that you want to build.
Sounds crazy, right? You're like, oh, but we're competitors.
A lot of people actually want to support other business owners.
And I'm not talking about, you know, the biggest names, I'm talking about relevant ones.
You know,
the course creator who built something sustainable and has been doing it for years,
not just the one who had a spectacular launch six months ago.
Look at the local business owner who's figured out how to market effectively in a regional community,
or the service provider who's built a profitable business without a massive following online.
And you know what?
These voices are often quieter because they're busy running their actual businesses rather than building personal brands around talking about their businesses.
But they're worth finding.
And when you find someone whose advice consistently resonates, whose context sensitive feels similar to yours, whose experience is really relevant,
whose track record is long enough to mean something,
go deep with them rather than, you know, wide across many voices,
the noise in the marketing advice space is genuinely overwhelming. And that comes from someone who's in the space.
And consuming less of it from more relevant sources is going to serve you better than consuming more of it from less relevant ones. I mean, a lot of them are amazing and spectacular at what they do, but is it really meaningful to you?
Okay,
I want to say something here because it feels right given everything I just shared.
This podcast is not exempt from the filter I've just described.
My advice comes from my experience and a lot of mentoring, like mentoring hundreds of clients across many different industries.
So yes, my advice comes from my experience, which is real, it's extensive,
and it is genuinely hard won.
But it also comes from my context,
from my business, from my community, from my market, from my clients.
I try to be conscious of that.
I try to flag when something is, you know, highly context dependent.
I try to give you frameworks for thinking rather than just telling you what to do.
And I try to be honest about what I don't know.
But you should still run everything I say through the filter. Of your own business.
Take what's relevant,
adapt what's close but you know not quite right, and leave what doesn't fit.
And that's not a criticism on my own podcast.
That's just how good marketing thinking works.
It starts with someone else's idea and ends with your own judgment about what's right for your specific situation.
Your judgment matters,
so trust it.
Whoa. So there you have it. Wow. The problem with following marketing advice from people who don't run businesses like yours and how to get smarter about filtering what you take in.
I want you to look at the marketing voices that you consume most regularly. You know, the podcast, Instagram accounts, the educators you follow,
and for each one I want you to ask, does their business resemble mine in waste that make their advice relevant? If yes, keep listening.
If not,
maybe it's time to find voices that are a better fit for where you actually are.
You don't need to consume less marketing content. You just need to consume more relevant marketing content from more relevant sources.
And if you want support thinking through what marketing actually makes sense for your specific business, for your model, your market, your resources, your community.
That's exactly what the Marketing Momentum membership is designed for.
Not generic advice,
but thinking that starts with your actual situation.
I will pop the link in the show notes. You can find more@newschoolofmarketing.com thank you so much for tuning in to the new School of Marketing podcast.
Just remember, not all marketing advice is created equal, and the most important filter you have is your own understanding of your own business.
I'm Bianca McKenzie and I'll catch you next week. Until then, keep making marketing work for you.